Skip to main content

Table 5 Ranking for combined error+noise and original images

From: Experimental study of image representation spaces in variational disparity calculation

Rank

Error + noise

MSE

Original images

MSE

1.

I+PHASE

72.3

I+HS(V)

35.1

2.

I

83.6

HS(V)+LOGD

37.5

3.

PHASE+|I|

84.1

I+RGB

39.0

4.

I+LOGD

87.4

I+RGBn

39.4

5.

PHASE

92.3

HS(V)+PHASE

40.6

6.

(r)ϕθ+PHASE

92.4

(r)ϕθ+PHASE

42.2

7.

I+|I|

92.6

I

44.9

8.

RGBn+LOGD

92.8

I +LOGD

45.6

9.

LOGD

97.5

I+PHASE

46.0

10.

RGB+PHASE

102.7

RGB+LOGD

46.0

11.

LOGD+|I|

105.5

RGBn+LOGD

46.8

12.

RGBn+|I|

111.5

RGBn+PHASE

47.1

13.

HS(V)+|I|

112.0

PHASE+|I|

47.7

14.

RGB+|I|

112.9

RGB+PHASE

47.9

15.

I+RGBn

114.8

PHASE

48.3

16.

RGBn+PHASE

120.0

LOGD

50.7

17.

HS(V)+PHASE

120.2

HS(V)+(r)ϕθ

53.2

18.

RGB+LOGD

125.7

(r)ϕθ

53.6

19.

I+(r)ϕθ

134.1

LOGD+|I|

55.2

20.

(r)ϕθ+|I|

139.8

HS(V)+|I|

55.9

21.

I+RGB

175.0

(r)ϕθ+|I|

56.9

22.

I+HS(V)

180.4

RGB+|I|

57.7

23.

HS(V)+LOGD

278.4

I+|I|

59.8

24.

HS(V)

293.8

RGBn+|I|

62.1

25.

RGB+HS(V)

360.8

RGBn+HS(V)

74.8

26.

RGBn+HS(V)

373.8

I+(r)ϕθ

99.3

27.

RGBn

374.4

(r)ϕθ+LOGD

103.7

28.

RGB

380.7

RGB+(r)ϕθ

119.4

29.

RGB+RGBn

394.3

HS(V)

134.3

30.

(r)ϕθ+LOGD

394.8

RGBn+(r)ϕθ

166.3

31.

HS(V)+(r)ϕθ

563.8

RGB+HS(V)

178.8

32.

(r)ϕθ

712.2

RGB

224.8

33.

RGBn+(r)ϕθ

716.7

RGB+RGBn

239.1

34.

RGB+(r)ϕθ

727.4

RGBn

260.3

  1. Combined error+noise is MSE of all the different illumination errors and noise types.