Skip to main content

Table 5 PSNR comparison for Gaussian blur plus Gaussian noise

From: A collaborative adaptive Wiener filter for image restoration using a spatial-domain multi-patch correlation model

Image Method PSNR (ISNR)
   Scenario Scenario Scenario Scenario
   I II III IV
Aerial Corrupted 22.64 20.79 19.98 18.88
491×434 L0-Abs 24.02 (1.38) 21.88 (1.10) 21.80 (1.82) 20.36 (1.48)
  TVMM 24.18 (1.54) 22.18 (1.40) 21.94 (1.95) 20.49 (1.60)
  BM3DDEB 24.41 (1.76) 22.56 (1.78) 22.54 (2.56) 21.32 (2.44)
  IDD-BM3D 24.71 (2.06) 22.69 (1.90) 22.71 (2.73) 21.32 (2.44)
  AWF 24.25 (1.61) 22.33 (1.55) 22.64 (2.66) 21.29 (2.41)
  CAWF 24.47 (1.83) 22.56 (1.78) 22.83 (2.85) 21.43 (2.55)
Bridge Corrupted 24.19 22.80 20.76 20.07
5122 L0-Abs 25.63 (1.44) 24.08 (1.28) 23.52 (2.77) 22.53 (2.47)
  TVMM 25.73 (1.53) 24.27 (1.47) 23.57 (2.82) 22.84 (2.77)
  BM3DDEB 26.02 (1.82) 24.71 (1.91) 24.47 (3.72) 23.62 (3.55)
  IDD-BM3D 26.23 (2.03) 24.79 (2.00) 24.52 (3.76) 23.63 (3.56)
  AWF 25.78 (1.59) 24.43 (1.63) 24.39 (3.63) 23.45 (3.38)
  CAWF 25.94 (1.74) 24.56 (1.77) 24.48 (3.72) 23.48 (3.41)
River Corrupted 22.14 20.66 19.69 18.79
(Kodak 11) L0-Abs 23.22 (1.08) 21.43 (0.77) 21.45 (1.76) 20.33 (1.54)
768×512 TVMM 23.13 (1.00) 21.52 (0.86) 21.14 (1.45) 20.33 (1.53)
  BM3DDEB 23.24 (1.11) 21.78 (1.12) 21.72 (2.03) 20.90 (2.11)
  IDD-BM3D 23.63 (1.49) 21.90 (1.24) 21.95 (2.26) 20.96 (2.17)
  AWF 23.29 (1.15) 21.78 (1.12) 22.06 (2.36) 21.06 (2.27)
  CAWF 23.48 (1.34) 21.93 (1.28) 22.21 (2.52) 21.15 (2.36)
Bones Corrupted 24.80 23.78 21.01 20.56
512×768 L0-Abs 26.07 (1.27) 25.14 (1.36) 24.65 (3.64) 24.17 (3.62)
  TVMM 25.94 (1.15) 25.11 (1.33) 24.52 (3.51) 24.24 (3.68)
  BM3DDEB 26.33 (1.54) 25.48 (1.71) 25.23 (4.22) 24.79 (4.23)
  IDD-BM3D 26.46 (1.66) 25.51 (1.74) 25.26 (4.24) 24.80 (4.24)
  AWF 26.31 (1.51) 25.37 (1.59) 25.25 (4.24) 24.69 (4.14)
  CAWF 26.44 (1.64) 25.43 (1.66) 25.28 (4.27) 24.67 (4.12)
Building Corrupted 22.60 21.27 19.96 19.18
768×512 L0-Abs 23.88 (1.28) 22.24 (0.97) 22.25 (2.29) 21.22 (2.04)
  TVMM 23.82 (1.22) 22.42 (1.16) 22.11 (2.15) 21.57 (2.39)
  BM3DDEB 23.86 (1.26) 22.53 (1.27) 22.49 (2.53) 21.73 (2.55)
  IDD-BM3D 24.25 (1.65) 22.69 (1.43) 22.75 (2.79) 21.85 (2.66)
  AWF 23.89 (1.28) 22.52 (1.26) 22.76 (2.80) 21.85 (2.66)
  CAWF 24.05 (1.45) 22.65 (1.38) 22.89 (2.93) 21.92 (2.74)
Gazebo Corrupted 23.29 21.90 20.31 19.55
768×512 L0-Abs 24.82 (1.53) 23.11 (1.21) 23.02 (2.71) 21.93 (2.38)
  TVMM 24.80 (1.50) 23.41 (1.50) 23.34 (3.03) 22.17 (2.61)
  BM3DDEB 24.91 (1.61) 23.45 (1.55) 23.39 (3.08) 22.52 (2.97)
  IDD-BM3D 25.29 (2.00) 23.65 (1.75) 23.68 (3.37) 22.66 (3.11)
  AWF 24.83 (1.53) 23.37 (1.47) 23.58 (3.26) 22.58 (3.03)
  CAWF 24.99 (1.69) 23.51 (1.61) 23.70 (3.39) 22.66 (3.10)