Skip to main content

Table 3 User positioning accuracy comparison of opportunistic signal Doppler measurements

From: Receiver architectures for positioning with low earth orbit satellite signals: a survey

User

Aid

Lowest RMSE [m]

Note

Ref.

Static

TLE, EKF

11.38

Experiment 25 SV, 4 minutes vs. simulation

[30]

Dynamic

IMU, altimeter, EKF

10.5

TLE and GNSS initialization

[22]

Static

altimeter, TLE

7.7 (2D)

Utilizing Starlink signals

[31]

Static

TLE, EKF

132 (2D)

Experiment multi-constellation

[5]

Static

TLE, altimeter

168 (2D)

Low signal environment tracking loop improvement

[32]

Dynamic

INS, TLE, EKF

200 to 1000

Aircraft trajectory calculation

[6]

Dynamic, Static

AoA, KF

100 (near base)

Feasibility study with base station and dynamic receiver

[33]