Skip to main content

Table 6 Estimated parameters of signal 2

From: Estimation of LFM signal parameters using RD compressed sampling and the DFRFT dictionary

Methods

(\(\widehat{p}_{{{\text{opt}}}}\), \(\widehat{u}_{{{\text{opt}}}}\))

(\(\widehat{k}\), \(\widehat{{f_{c} }}\))

Error (\(\widehat{k}\))

Error (\(\widehat{{f_{c} }}\))

Operation time/s

QPSO

(0.81, 454)

(− 307.8, 102.9)

0.026

0.029

12.23

 

(0.81, 549)

(− 307.8, 204.5)

 

0.025

 

(0.81, 645)

(− 307.8, 305.1)

 

0.017

 

(0.81, 738)

(− 307.8, 407.7)

 

0.019

GA-PSO

(0.81, 454)

(− 307.8, 102.9)

0.026

0.029

24.33

 

(0.81, 549)

(− 307.8, 204.5)

 

0.025

 

(0.81, 645)

(− 307.8, 305.1)

 

0.017

 

(0.81, 738)

(− 307.8, 407.7)

 

0.019

PSO

(0.79, 443)

(− 323.9,109.3)

0.080

0.093

74.33

 

(0.79, 545)

(− 323.9, 217.5)

 

0.088

 

(0.79, 641)

(− 323.9, 329.2)

 

0.097

 

(0.79, 729)

(− 323.9, 438.5)

 

0.096

2-DS

(0.81, 454)

(− 307.8, 102.9)

0.026

0.029

684

 

(0.81, 549)

(− 307.8, 204.5)

 

0.025

 

(0.81, 645)

(− 307.8, 305.1)

 

0.017

 

(0.81, 738)

(− 307.8, 407.7)

 

0.019

  1. Bold values indicate the best performance among the different methods