# Two-Dimensional Harmonic Retrieval in Correlative Noise Based on Genetic Algorithm

- Sun-Yong Wu
^{1, 2}Email author, - Gui-Sheng Liao
^{1}Email author and - Zhi-Wei Yang
^{1}

**2010**:569371

https://doi.org/10.1155/2010/569371

© Sun-Yong Wu et al. 2010

**Received: **30 December 2009

**Accepted: **16 June 2010

**Published: **7 July 2010

## Abstract

We propose a niche Genetic algorithm (GA) for the two-dimensional (2D) harmonic retrieval in the presence of correlative zero-mean, multiplicative, and additive noise. Firstly, we introduce a 2D fourth-order time-average moment spectrum which has extremum values at the harmonic frequencies. On this basis, the problem of harmonic retrieval is treated as a problem of finding the extremum values for which the niche GA is resorted. Utilizing the global searching ability of the GA, this method can improve the frequency estimation performance. The effectiveness of the proposed algorithm is demonstrated through computer simulations.

## Keywords

## 1. Introduction

2D harmonic retrieval is of interest in signal processing such as sonar, radar, geophysics, and radio astronomy. In the case of additive noise, some high-resolution techniques such as the 2D MUSIC [1], the 2D MEMP [2], and the 2D ESPRIT method [3] have been developed from their 1D versions. Of these algorithms, the ESPIRIT algorithm is more effective as it does not require to search for the peak value in a 2D space. Different from the above methods considering white noise, in the presence of colored Gaussian noise, Ibrahim and Gharieb [4, 5] have presented some methods based on fourth-order cumulants since the cumulants are insensitive to Gaussian noise while they contain frequency and phase information.

Under certain circumstances, the amplitudes of the received harmonic signals are random since they are usually corrupted by multiplicative noise. For example, multiplicative noise is encountered in underwater acoustic applications due to the dispersive medium [6, 7], and random amplitude modulation occurs in Doppler-radar signals when the target scintillates or when the point target assumption is no longer valid [8]. Techniques based on cyclic statistics have been proposed to estimate the 2D harmonic frequencies in multiplicative noise [9, 10]. However, these methods are based on the assumption that multiplicative and additive noises are mutually independent and mixing.

In practice, the correlation of the multiplicative and additive noise should be considered. In correlative multiplicative and additive noise, Wu and Li [11] has studied the problem of the quadratic nonlinear coupling of 2D harmonics based on 2D third-order time-average moment spectrum. Another two new 2D cyclic statistics are also introduced to estimate the harmonic frequencies in [12, 13], respectively. However, both the methods suffer from a resolution limit and no strategy of searching for the extremum values is discussed. In this paper, we propose a new strategy to improve the frequency estimation performance. Since the fourth-order time-average moment spectrum defined in [13] peaks at the harmonic frequencies, the harmonic retrieval can be treated as finding the extremum values in a 2D space. Utilizing the global searching ability, a GA-based algorithm is presented to estimate the frequencies of 2D harmonic corrupted by correlative multiplicative and additive noise. Simulation examples show that the improved frequency estimation can be achieved.

The organization of the paper is as follows. In Section 2, we introduce a special 2D fourth-order time-average moment spectrum. In Section 3, a GA-based algorithm is proposed to estimate harmonic frequencies. Numerical examples are presented in Section 4, and conclusions are drawn in Section 5.

## 2. 2D Harmonic Model

where denotes the th frequency pair and represents the th phase. and denote multiplicative and additive noise, respectively. In this paper, the following assumptions are given by

Note that if the variance , the model in (1) would become the classical case of harmonics with constant amplitude in additive noise. The first assumption ensures that the fourth-order time-average moment spectrum which will be defined latter peaks at the harmonic frequencies. The second assumption ensures the identifiability of harmonic phases. In the third assumption, without loss of generality, the mean of the additive noise can be assumed to be zero. A nonzero mean can always be estimated consistently via the sample mean and then subtracted from the data. When the mean of multiplicative noise , Wang et al. [9] and Yang and Li [10] have presented some effective methods to estimate the harmonic frequencies.

Generally, and are always assumed to be mixing and mutually independent [6–10]. In order to describe the correlativity of multiplicative and additive noise, Xu et al. [12] derived the cross mixing condition. If and are mixing and mutually independent, they are also cross mixing. On the contrary, if and are cross mixing, they must be mixing, but it doesn't mean that they are mutually independent. The correlativity of multiplicative and additive noise can be described by cross-mixing condition. The cross-mixing property implies that samples of the processes that are well separated in time can be regarded as approximately independent [14]. Under the cross-mixing condition, time averages of the cyclic statistics converge in the mean-square sense to their sample averages. In model (1), if and are cross-mixing, the observed signal is cyclostationary, and the sample estimates of its cyclic statistics converge in the sense of mean square and are asymptotically normal [15].

Definition 1.

Definition 2.

Theorem 1.

where is Kronecker function. Equation (6) contains harmonic frequency information. This relation will be proved in the appendix.

From (6),
is unequal to zero only if
, or
. According to Assumption 1,
, the number of the obtained greatest maxima of
should be *L* rather than
in the
plane.

where a.s. represents*almost sure convergence* which is uniform in
and
. Equation (8) means that the single record estimator
is strongly consistent. Alternatively, we can estimate the harmonic frequencies by searching for
greatest maxima of
in the
plane. Consequently, the frequency estimation of 2D harmonics can be treated as finding the extremum values of binary function. In this paper, the GA is proposed to seek
local optimum solutions.

## 3. Genetic Algorithm Realization

GA is nowadays one of the most popular stochastic optimization techniques which is inspired by natural genetics and biological evolutionary process. It is supposed that individuals with more adaptability in current generation would have better capability of survival and breeding in the next generation. One of the most important advantages of GA is that it can make use of the limited searching processes to automatically find the optimal or near-optimal result in the solution space. Compared with the classical optimization algorithms, GA has such features as follows [17].

- (1)
GA starts from multipoints instead of one point. Thereby, it could effectively prevent the searching processes from stopping in local optimum solutions.

- (2)
The optimization rule of GA is varied. It is determined by probability.

- (3)
The fitness is calculated only from object function. No other information is necessary.

- (4)
It automatically seeks the optimal result in the whole solution space.

- (5)
The calculation is relatively simple.

GA evaluates a population and generates a new one iteratively, with each successive population referred to as a generation. Assume the current generation is . After applying a set of genetic operations, the GA generates a new generation based on the previous generation. Three basic operators are used to manipulate the genetic composition of a population: selection, crossover, and mutation [17].

The detailed implementation of the proposed method is given as follows.

Generation of the Initial Group

Commonly in GA, the initial population is randomly generated. The real-coded GA is adopted in this paper. The length of chromosome graph is set as 3. The first two genes denote the frequency pairs and the third gene denotes the fitness value.

The performance of GA is influenced heavily by the population size. GA may run the risk of serious under-covering of the solution space and result in a local optimum when the population size is relatively small, whereas GA would increase the computational load when the population size is relatively large. Consequently, the population size should be chosen according to the problem scale.

The operation is to choose the good individual and get rid of the bad one from the group. The larger the fitness, the larger probability the individual has to be selected. To achieve this, the roulette wheel selection is used. The fitness of the th individual is denoted as . The selection probability of the th individual is computed as . At the same time, we reserve the best individual to the next population.

where is a uniformly distributed random number in .

where positive number controls the dependence degree of random fluctuation to evolution number and are uniformly distributed as random numbers on the interval . is the largest evolution number.

Condition to Terminate the GA Iterations

When the number of generation reaches , the iterations would be terminated.

In this paper, we seek all the optimal solutions of nonlinear function , including local optimal solutions and global optimal solutions. However, the simple genetic algorithm is unable to get all optimal solutions. According to the niche phenomenon in nature [19, 20], a niche GA-based method is proposed to estimate harmonic frequencies. A niche in nature can be viewed as a subspace in the environment. Accordingly, a niche is commonly thought as a peak of the fitness function. The niche techniques gather the individuals on several peaks of fitness function in the population according to genetic likeness. The structure of a niche is implemented by decreasing the fitness value of the individual. The concrete method is implemented by calculating the Euclidean distance between parent individual and arbitrary other child individual and then judging whether two individuals are in the circle defined by estimating niche radius . Compare with simple GA, niche GA can find more than one optima during evolution. The basic steps of the algorithm are given as follows.

- (1)
Set the generation number . Create an initial population which includes individuals and evaluate their fitness.

- (2)
- (3)
Produce a new population through selection, crossover and mutation.

- (4)
Evaluate the fitness of every new individual.

- (5)
Keep the individuals from step 3 and memorial individuals from step 2. Evaluate the distance

*d*between each two of them. Introduce a penalty to the individual with lower fitness when . - (6)
Combine the individuals with the individuals. Sort the individuals according to their fitness. Save the first individuals and the first individuals.

- (7)

## 4. Simulations

Example 1.

The GA parameters are set as follows. Initial population , memorial population , genetic times , crossover probability , mutation probability , mutation control parameter , niche destining distance , and individual penalty .

Example 2.

## 5. Conclusion

In this paper, a cyclic statistics-based method for frequency estimation of 2D harmonics in correlative multiplicative and additive noise is addressed. Since the 2D fourth-order time-average moment spectrum peaks at the frequencies of harmonic, the problem of harmonic retrieval can be solved by finding the extremum values. Exploiting global searching ability of GA and the niche phenomenon in nature, we propose a niche GA method to estimate harmonic frequencies. This method can improve the estimation accuracy. Simulation results demonstrated the effectiveness of the presented method. Moreover, our method can be extended to the parameter estimation of 2D harmonics under other conditions.

## Declarations

### Acknowledgments

The authors would like to thank the anonymous reviewers for their constructive comments and suggestions that helped to improve the paper. This work is supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China under Grants nos. 60736009 and 60901066.

## Authors’ Affiliations

## References

- Odendaal JW, Barnard E, Pistorius CWI: Two-dimensional superresolution radar imaging using the MUSIC algorithm.
*IEEE Transactions on Antennas and Propagation*1994, 42(10):1386-1391. 10.1109/8.320744View ArticleGoogle Scholar - Hua Y: Estimating two-dimensional frequencies by matrix enhancement and matrix pencil.
*IEEE Transactions on Signal Processing*1992, 40(9):2267-2280. 10.1109/78.157226View ArticleMATHGoogle Scholar - Rouquette S, Najim M: Estimation of frequencies and damping factors by two-dimensional ESPRIT type methods.
*IEEE Transactions on Signal Processing*2001, 49(1):237-245. 10.1109/78.890367View ArticleGoogle Scholar - Ibrahim HM, Gharieb RR: Estimating two-dimensional frequencies by a cumulant-based FBLP method.
*IEEE Transactions on Signal Processing*1999, 47(1):262-266. 10.1109/78.738268View ArticleGoogle Scholar - Gharieb RR: Cumulant-based LP method for two-dimensional spectral estimation.
*IEEE Proceedings: Vision, Image and Signal Processing*1999, 146(6):307-312. 10.1049/ip-vis:19990743Google Scholar - Giannakis GB, Zhou G: Harmonics in multiplicative and additive noise: parameter estimation using cyclic statistics.
*IEEE Transactions on Signal Processing*1995, 43(9):2217-2221. 10.1109/78.414790View ArticleGoogle Scholar - Dwyer RF: Fourth-order spectra of Gaussian amplitude-modulated sinusoids.
*Journal of the Acoustical Society of America*1991, 90(2):918-926. 10.1121/1.401958View ArticleGoogle Scholar - Besson O, Stoica P: Sinusoidal signals with random amplitude: least-squares estimators and their statistical analysis.
*IEEE Transactions on Signal Processing*1995, 43(11):2733-2744. 10.1109/78.482122View ArticleGoogle Scholar - Wang F, Wang S-X, Dou H-J: Two-dimensional parameter estimation using two-dimensional cyclic statistics.
*Journal of Electronics*2003, 31(10):1522-1525.Google Scholar - Yang S-Y, Li H-W: Two-dimensional harmonics parameters estimation using third-order cyclic-moments.
*Journal of Electronics*2005, 33(10):1808-1811.Google Scholar - Wu S, Li H: The analysis of two-dimensional quadratic coupled harmonics in the complex noise based on genetic algorithm.
*Signal Processing Journal*2006, 22: 635-638.Google Scholar - Xu J, Wang S-X, Wang H: Harmonic retrieval and nonlinear frequency-coupled harmonics in the complex noise.
*Journal of Electronics*2003, 31: 117-122.Google Scholar - Dou H, Wang S-X, Wang F: Two-dimensional harmonics retrieval in correlative multiplication and additive noise.
*Proceedings of the 7th International Conference on Signal Processing (ICSP '04), September 2004, Beijing, China*264-268.Google Scholar - Brillinger DR:
*Time Series: Data Analysis and Theory*. Holden-day, San Francisco, Calif, USA; 1981.MATHGoogle Scholar - Dandawate AV, Giannakis GB: Asymptotic theory of mixed time averages and kth-order cyclic-moment and cumulant statistics.
*IEEE Transactions on Information Theory*1995, 41(1):216-232. 10.1109/18.370106MathSciNetView ArticleMATHGoogle Scholar - Li H, Cheng Q, Yuan B: Strong laws of large numbers for two-dimensional processes.
*Proceedings of the 4th International Conference on Signal Processing (ICSP '98), October 1998, Beijing, China*43-46.Google Scholar - Goldberg DE:
*Genetic Algorithms in Search, Optimization and Machine Learning*. Addison-Wesley, Reading, Mass, USA; 1989.MATHGoogle Scholar - Michalewicz Z:
*Genetic Algorithms + Data Structures = Evolution Programs*. 3rd edition. Springer, New York, NY, USA; 1999.MATHGoogle Scholar - Deb K, Coldberg DE: An investigation of niche and species formation in genetic function optimization. In
*Proceedings of the 3rd Conference on Genetic Algorithms (ICGA '89), 1989, San Mateo, Calif, USA*. Morgan Kaufmann; 42-50.Google Scholar - Zhou M, Sun S:
*The Theory and Application of Genetic Algorithm*. The Press of National Defence and Industry, Beijing, China; 1999.Google Scholar - Yang S, Li H: Estimation of the number of harmonics in multiplicative and additive noise.
*Signal Processing*2007, 87(5):1128-1137. 10.1016/j.sigpro.2006.10.011View ArticleMATHGoogle Scholar - Yang S, Li H: Estimating the number of harmonics using enhanced matrix.
*IEEE Signal Processing Letters*2007, 14(2):137-140.View ArticleGoogle Scholar

## Copyright

This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.