 Research
 Open Access
 Published:
Modeling of a method of parallel hierarchical transformation for fast recognition of dynamic images
EURASIP Journal on Advances in Signal Processing volume 2013, Article number: 87 (2013)
Abstract
Principles necessary to develop a method and computational facilities for the parallel hierarchical transformation based on highperformance GPUs are discussed in the paper. Mathematic models of the parallel hierarchical (PH) network training for the transformation and a PH network training method for recognition of dynamic images are developed.
1. Introduction
Rapidly growing requirements to modern computational media encourage the development of new intelligent methods of information transfer and processing. Rigid requirements to realtime information processing systems force scientists to develop and regularly upgrade data transfer systems. Today, most internet channels cannot provide required quality of data exchange between such systems, leading to the congestion of those channels and formation of socalled digital bottlenecks. Large volumes of information may be transferred easily through a fiberoptic cable, but laying such cable is rather expensive, even on short distances. At the same time, this problem can be solve using laserbased technologies [1–3], one of the most promising models of information transfer for the near future. In this case, for instance, tons of fulllength films and virtual worlds could be transferred to any part of the globe in a blink of an eye.
Most satellites transmit information, such as TV programs, by means of the microwave radiation, while laserbased information transmission could be hundreds of times faster, considerably increasing a carrying capacity of the channel. The laserbased information transmission requires that both satellite and receiving unit (RU) were positioned properly. A position of the RU lens, the diameter of which is only several centimeters, must be adjusted to one thousandth degree, or the information will not be transferred.
To operate properly, the system requires that a RU monitors a satellite at all stages of the system operation. For this purpose, an occurrence of laser beam spot (LBS) on images, namely, their geometrical characteristics distorted by the turbulence and air masses, should be predicted accurately.
However, significant noise distortion of those images can not only considerably worsen forecast results but also prevent the system from responding adequately to variations in the monitored object location. To solve a problem of the efficient forecast, frames of the LBS image sequence should be classified to filter a laser route from images considerably distorted by noise, thus forming a tunnel of reference images [see Additional file 1].
Additional file 1:Title: Importance of laser beam profiling systems in telecommunications. Description: Importance of research in the area of development of new methods and means of laser beam profiling and classification of laser spot images in telecommunication systems is explained in this video. A need to use developed means in the tasks of image transfer, processing, and classification for optical communications is demonstrated. (MOV 4 MB)
Development of computerized realtime forecasting systems gained new momentum with the emergence of highefficiency automated systems of information collection, processing, and storage. Such systems include a number of tools able to classify and forecast characteristics of respective objects, phenomena, or realtime processes based on special algorithms and geometric characteristics of object boundaries. Fragments of laser beam routes used in the optical communication, navigation, ranging, and military equipment are studied in this paper. The development of the parallel hierarchical (PH) networkbased forecasting systems allows the solution of a problem in automatic object control, laserbased data transfer, and forecasting the moving optical object behavior.
Today, highperformance fast calculations are extremely important as information volumes are still growing, and computational complexity is increasing. The most significant problems include operative response and realtime decisionmaking, highresolution video data processing, and classification and forecasting of quickchanging dynamic data [4–6].
Highperformance fast calculations are developed quite well and have many applied aspects, helping solve complex problems. Neurocomputers have many advantages as compared to regular Harvard structure computers, but they also have one significant drawback: their price; as a result, some alternatives should be sought.
One of the most efficient methods to process large data arrays is parallel processing based on specialized system solutions, in particular, on the neurallike parallel hierarchical systems. However, LBS hardware implementation of such systems faces a problem of selecting an adequate platform for fast and efficient parallel processing of data bulk.
A hierarchic transformation is an important and powerful computing operation. This motivates the studies of parallel approaches, such as graphical processing units, or low level complexity algorithms, such as the adaptive resonance theory (ART). Though ART was realized with graphic processing units (GPUs), there are a few hierarchical applications of GPU ART. Every ART layer is propagating in the GPU while being trained at the same time. Experimental results show that for deep trees, graphic processors should be used due to the significant advantage of GPUs.
Programming of GPUs using NVIDIA Compute Unified Device Architecture (CUDA) technology is of interest in the computational systems, especially for population algorithms [7–9]. This is important when GPU [10, 11] programming is used to achieve certain advantages in hierarchical transformation algorithms [12, 13].
ART is attractive for hierarchical transformation due to its speed and scalability to the parallel transformation [14]. However, GPUbased ART has not been developed earlier. Its only drawback is the rigidity of memory usage for the core value if a set of dynamic arrays is restricted to the CPU exclusively. Typical tree algorithms provide pointers for the creation of both a node and a reference [15], which is inefficient when the CUDA technology is used. In [16–18], the implemented GPU programming focused on the behavior of a single ART unit; however, a hierarchical transformation requires a different approach. Architecture of such transformation is based on the pipeline processing structure [19].
A method of organization of the multilayer tree structure composed on CUDA platformbased units is described in [20]. Presented experimental results demonstrate an increase in performance for different data sets and parameters that were compared with those obtained with regular CPUs.
A goal of this paper is to develop and apply the suggested method and means of parallel hierarchical transformation for fast recognition of dynamic images, namely, those of LBSs. A method of parallel hierarchical transformation based on the normalizing equation allows computational structures to accelerate. Unlike prevalent types of video information encoding (for instance, differential encoding, codepulse encoding, and delta modulation), which are based on the sequential encoding of difference information, an approach suggested here processes the results of the data array encoding distributed in the spacetime domain.
In addition, the use of the normalizing equation allows a preliminary procedure of image classification by forming tuning coefficients to be realized quite simply, thus determining weighting coefficients for each class. In particular, to perform a realtime classification and analysis of, for instance, adjacent frames of a multimedia image, the use of the normalizing equation gives better results in comparison to other approaches [21].
Specifically, this research aims to analyze a sequence of LBS image frames forming separate routes. Each route is formed from fragments obtained from the receiver with a frequency of 40 ms. Each image of the pattern has a dimension of 128 × 128 decomposition elements.
The paper consists of the following parts: Description of parallelhierarchical transformation algorithms, software modeling and efficiency of the PH transformation, experimental results and physical modeling of the PH transformation for fast recognition of LBS images, and conclusions.
2.1 A method of parallel hierarchical transformation with formation of the normalizing equation for fast image recognition
Application of the masking method of information processing for fast recognition of LBS images [22] indicates a need to improve a method of the parallel hierarchical transformation. A task to train the suggested PH network by analogy with training in the radial basis function (RBF) networks is in practice brought down to the controlled training of initiallayer network elements. Based on the general idea of the structural organization of artificial neurallike networks as ‘input layer  hidden layer  output layer, it is possible to produce a trainable PH network, where the first network level serves as an input layer, levels 2 to k (where k is a number of the hidden layer levels) serve as hidden layers, and the output layer, which is traditionally used in artificial neurallike networks, serves as an output layer (Figure 1):
An organizational structure of the multilayer PH network is shown in Figure 2.
A number of hiddenlayer elements can be determined from the network algorithm length, accordingly formalizing a calculation procedure of the number of hiddenlayer elements. Averaged values of weighting coefficients are determined by formula (1):
where N is a dimensionality of the taught sample P. r is the PH network hidden layer number.
A system of equations to determine tuning coefficients w _{1} ^{r} − w _{ k − 1} ^{r} can be composed as system (2):
where $\sum _{t=2}^{k}{a}_{11}^{t}$ is the reference frame component of the extended route being recognized. $\sum _{i}{a}_{i}^{k}$ and ${a}_{11}^{2}{a}_{11}^{k}$ are the current frame components of the extended route being recognized.
After finding values w _{1} − w _{ k − 1}, a normalizing Equation (3) can be formed:
To normalize results of the PH network with tuning coefficients (2), the main property of the PH network will be used: $\sum _{t=2}^{k}{a}_{11}^{t}}={\displaystyle \sum _{i}{a}_{i}$[21]. Then, a right part of the normalizing Equation (3) represents a ratio of the sum of products of averaged tuning coefficients and tail elements to the sum of the tail elements of the network.
With the correct recognition of LBS images, this normalized measure d → 1. The similarity of the images being recognized is measured by a degree of its closeness to 1.
Using the normalizing Equation (3), where ${\overline{w}}_{1}^{R}={\overline{w}}_{2}^{R}=\dots ={\overline{w}}_{k2}^{R}={\overline{w}}_{k1}^{R}=1$, it is possible for a fixed value of d to formulate quite easily a preliminary procedure of image classification and then, according to system (2), form tuning coefficients ${\overline{w}}_{1}{\overline{w}}_{k1}$, thus determining weighting coefficients for each class.
In particular, for the realtime classification and analysis of adjacent frames of extended laser beam routes, the normalizing Equation (3) acquires form (4):
where ${\left({\displaystyle \sum _{t=2}^{k}{a}_{11}^{t}}\right)}^{j}$ is a sum of k − 1 tail elements. j is a frame number, where $j=\overline{1,m1}$, and ${\left({a}_{11}^{2}\right)}^{j+1}{\left({a}_{11}^{k}\right)}^{j+1}$ is a value of tail elements of images of the previous (j th) and following ((j + 1)th) frames, respectively.
Given the abovementioned property of the PH network, the normalizing Equation (3) acquires form (5):
Because in calculating expression (5), there is no need to determine tail elements ${\left({a}_{11}^{2}\right)}^{j+1}{\left({a}_{11}^{k}\right)}^{j+1}$ to process the (j + 1)th frame. A recognition time significantly decreases for normalized results of input data processing (a _{1} − a _{ N }) in comparison to the known neurallike networks, where input data of the j th frame cannot be used for recognition in the initial layer of the (j + 1)th frame.
To realize a parallel hierarchical transformation for fast recognition of LBS images, an average value ${\overline{a}}_{i}^{t}$ should be selected from the available digital information and rounded to the closest integer; then, two connected PH networks should be formed to process positive and negative difference components. In this case, for each of those PH networks, a system of equations can be formed, where the roots for all equations except for the first one are pairs of tuning coefficients (2):

for positive difference components: (w _{1} ^{r(+)}??w _{ k  1} ^{r(+)})

for negative difference components: (w _{1} ^{r()}??w _{ k  1} ^{r()}).
For the first layer of the PH network, only the tuning coefficient w _{1} ^{r(+)} is being calculated because there are only positive difference components here.
When processing a sequence of extended laser route images, it will be more appropriate to use a normalizing equation for two adjacent image frames, where the first image is taken as the reference one. Then, the normalizing equation will have form (6):
where ${\overline{w}}_{1}{\overline{w}}_{k}$ are tuning coefficients obtained during the preliminary processing on the first images of the set; (a _{11} ^{t})^{j}, (a _{11} ^{t})^{j − 1} are tail elements of the current and previous images, respectively.
Usually, when processing a sequence of extended laser route images, it is necessary to detect ‘bad’ images, or those internal and external contours of which are most distorted by atmosphere, and exclude those from the route analysis. Because the normable criterion (6) can be found for both a single frame of the laser route, and for the laser route as a whole, we can form a set А from coefficients d _{ i } (7):
where N is a number of frames of the laser route.
Because d is a measure of correspondence between tuning coefficients of the reference PH network and those of the current network, the і th elements of the set (7), which have low values, can be classified as ‘bad’ images:
where χ is a determined threshold criterion. As 0 ≤ d ≤ 1, then 0 ≤ χ ≤ 1. Experiment demonstrated that the threshold criterion (9) should be set within limits (9) for insignificant image deformations and within limits (10) in case of more substantial deformations.
For the quality classification and processing of a sequence of extended laser route frames, this threshold criterion may be used in ‘tighter’ limits (9):
For those laser routes which contain images significantly distorted by atmospheric agents, it is recommended to set less strict limits of the threshold value (10):
2.2 The computational efficiency of the developed method of parallel hierarchical transformation in comparison with other existing transformations
The number of computational operations used for the PH transformation is N(N + 1), where N is the total number of elements processed. For comparison, the number of operations used in other transformations widely applied in practice, e.g., orthogonal transformations, are the following: 4 N ^{2} log _{2} N for fast Fourier transformation, 2 N ^{2} log _{2} N ^{2} for Hadamard, and 4 N(N + 1) for Haar.
Absence of timeconsuming operations indicates a sufficient simplicity of the computational procedure that realizes the parallel hierarchical transformation and makes it an efficient method for use in various applied areas requiring a combination of a high level of the parallelism and a compact form of data representation.
3.1 Development of the parallel hierarchical transformation algorithms
A general algorithm for fast recognition of LBS images can be developed based on the suggested method of the parallel hierarchical transformation for processing dynamic images (Figure 3):
This algorithm envisages a call to subroutine NetForm (NETFORM Engineering Machinery Metal Ltd., Turkey), a subprogram serving to construct network structures for images. A detailed description of the subroutine is shown as an algorithm (Figure 4):
This subroutine inputs the initial information to the PH network. After that, Gtransformation of information [21] takes place at all levels of the PH network. The Gtransformation is performed in the following way. A vector of incoming image is sent to the PH network input (to input elements of firstlevel branches of the network, Figure 1). A mathematical model of the parallel decomposition of the set $\mu =\left\{{a}_{i}\right\},i=\stackrel{\_\_\_\_\_}{1,n}$[21], used in each branch of the PH network, looks as follows:
where a _{ i } ≠ 0.P is a dimensionality of this set (a number of set elements) or a dimensionality of the PH network branch of its every level. a ^{z}, $z=\overline{1}$, and $\overline{P}$ are the elements of subsets consisting of equal elements; n _{ z } is a number of elements in the k th subset (i.e., order of number a _{ i }), and ${a}^{{j}^{\ast}}$ is an element of the set {a ^{z}}, selected at the j ^{*}th step, ${j}^{\ast}=\overline{1,P}$, a ^{0} = 0, n _{0} = 0.
When a structure of the two networks is constructed, the average values of weighting coefficients and tuning coefficients (4) are being determined. Based on the calculated tuning coefficients, a normalizing Equation (6) is being formed.
If an average value ${\overline{a}}_{i}^{t}$ is rounded to the closest integer, subroutine PosNegNets is called. It is a subprogram that forms two connected PH networks for the processing of positive and negative difference components. A formation algorithm of the two networks is similar to the formation algorithms of the network structure for images. After that, a normalizing criterion (7) for the route as a whole is being found with further classification of images into good and bad according to ratio (8). If the threshold criterion is determined, the classification is conducted again. Let us develop a preliminary processing algorithm of route fragments (Figure 5).
An image of the laser route fragment arriving to the system input undergoes the following preliminary processing:

1.
Determine maximum fragment brightness to form n border lines.

2.
Having selected a necessary number of boundaries, find their geometrical centers and average parameters for the whole frame.

3.
Form tunnel boundaries using a trained sample and averaged frame parameters.

4.
Check if calculated frame parameters are included into the tunnel. Based on this verification, frame image classification is performed. If an image was classified as bad, the image parameters are corrected and included into the taught sample; then, an additional training of the system is performed.
3.2 Program modeling and application efficiency of the parallel hierarchical transformation for fast recognition of LBS images
The developed application is intended to process and classify the LBS images. The software window (Figure 6) represents a form divided into two parts: the left part contains a processing panel of the reference frame of the LBS images route, and the right one that of the current frame of the LBS images route.
Information about the frame parameters is exhibited in the upper part:
frame width, pixels;

frame height, pixels;

information about the route containing the frame;

frame file name;

number of frames in the route.
The bottom part contains tabs:

construction of the network graph, which can be obtained and saved as a PH network graph file;

route fragment processing, where a route fragment can be processed;

image comparison, where LBS images being compared and classified;

determination of energy centers, where LBS energy centers are determined and the PH network is trained.
An energy center is a point in the image, where coordinates (x,y) of a twodimensional signal with a specific nonlinear density w(f(x,y)) meet a given value of f(x,y) and are expressed as follows:
where M is the first order moment of inertia.
To estimate the efficiency of the suggested algorithms and the soft hardware that developed on their basis, let us describe the technical advantages of means of the PH transformation as demonstrated by the developed products and conducted experiments. The comparative characteristic is shown in Table 1.
The use of neurallike network technologies for the classification of extended laser route images is analyzed in [22]. The computer modeling revealed 92.5% correctly recognized images, including 74% good images and 60% bad images. In [23], a recognition system was modeled on the basis of the MLP neurallike network and RBFbased neurallike network. Recognition of a sample that included 140 laser route spot objects by the RBFbased neurallike network modeled in the Statistica Neural Networks 4.0 (StatSoft Inc., Moscow, Russia) yielded 92% correctly recognized images. Comparing the results of [22, 23] and those studied in this article, the latter has more potential.
Therefore, the suggested method, algorithms, and soft hardware permit to measure the energy center coordinates of the laser route fragment images based on the normalizing equation with accuracy of no more than 0.01 decomposition elements, thus exceeding known methods (e.g., based on determination of the gravity center using the method of moment characteristics [24–27]) by accuracy 1.5 times on average, which is reflected in Table 1. A time necessary for preliminary and network processing of laser route fragment images decreases, too.
4 Experimental results and physical modeling of the parallel hierarchical transformation for fast recognition of LBS images
Four routes, each containing 100 frames, were used in the experimental research of the parallel hierarchical transformation for fast recognition of LBS images. Using the normalizing Equation (6), let us determine the normalized measures for route 1 (Figure 7).
Using Equations (8) and (9), let us classify the images (Figure 8).
As we see, a portion of good images is 18%. As a rule, in real conditions, positions of energy centers cannot be determined absolutely accurately; therefore, less tight limits should be set for the threshold criterion using relation (10) (Figures 9 and 10):
An average portion of the good images in this case is 40% and 59%, respectively. Then, the PH network is trained for repeated processing of the bad route fragments. In physical modeling of the method of PH transformation and determination of extended laser rout image coordinates using the graphic adapter Radeon X1300 (Advanced Micro Devices, Inc., Sunnyvale, USA), processing of a single image takes about 0.6 s. Radeon X1300 is a basic solution in the ATI Radeon family of graphic adapters based on the graphic processor RV515 with main characteristics of four pixel pipelines, four texture units, and two vertex pipelines [28].
An approach of flow programming is suggested to program the GPU. This approach includes splitting a program into relatively small stages (core programs) that process data flow elements. Core programs go into shaders, and data flows go into textures in the GPU. A shader is a program performed on the GPU and processes a data flow. The ‘data flow’ means information about coordinates of polygon vertices, each vertex illumination, normal, texture coordinates, and so on, which permanently arrives in blocs to the shader program. A video processor receives outgoing information for all three vertices of the polygon. Having data on the three vertices, the GPU goes through all pixels of a single polygon, while gradually changing (interpolating) vertex values from one vertex to another. A shader length is a memory space of the shader program. Considering that data arriving to the shader is random for the programmer in a sense that an order in which the data will be sent to the shader is not preset, the shader program does not have any statistical or general variables. Otherwise, the shader program is similar to a regular C program. There are input, output and time variables, standard functions, structures, arrays, cycles, and conditional operators.
Image processing takes place on the GPU with cores realized at all elements covered by the initial region. The only obvious way to calculate a scalar of the input vector is to represent 1 × 1 initial elements and use a core that is read in all values from the input texture. This approach has several drawbacks. First, only one of the parallel elementary processors would be busy. Second, that would probably exceed a maximum memory size, including memory of the shader and static instruction of calculation for some hardware. That is why we will perform a parallel operation of reduction based on global methods of communication on parallel computers.
At the high level, GPUbased parallel calculation is a correction of sizes of the input and output texture and of index elements. For the presented vector M of the length M, the output of the first step is M/2 with texture M/2. For each of its elements, the coordinates for input texture are corrected in such a way that they correspond to disconnected 2 × 2 subregions. Then, the values in those subregions are compared. This is repeated recursively until the 2 × 2 texture is reduced finally to the 1 × 1 ‘scalar’ texture through a logarithmic series of repetitions.
Next, the series of images finalize the first step of the 8 × 8 algorithm reduction of the input texture (Figure 11a). Figure 11a demonstrates the input texture. The initial elements are marked in green. Figure 11b is a result of the first round of reduction. Each initial element contains a local transfer maximum of the 2 × 2 subregion in the input texture (marked in blue and orange). This relation, in addition, is distinguished in the second line of images (Figure 11b).
Let us determine the coordinates of the energy centers of the fragment of route 1 (Figure 12).
A diagram of changes in the energy center coordinates of route 1 fragments is shown in Figure 13.
After the PH network training, a portion of the good images was 83% (as compared to 18%). The graphic interpretation of the determination of energy center coordinates after the PH network training is demonstrated in Figures 14 and 15.
After the PH network training, a portion of the good images of route 2 was 76% (12% before training), as shown in Figures 16 and 17.
After the PH network training, a portion of the good images of route 3 fragments was 65% (15% before training), as shown in Figures 18 and 19.
After the PH network training, a portion of good images of route 3 reached 83% as compared to 17% before training (Figure 20).
5 Conclusions
The paper deals with an important problem of improved efficiency of dynamic image recognition. The analyses of modern trends in the development of fast recognition technologies for dynamic images, as well as the analysis of the PH transformation development, classify the suggested parallel hierarchical approach as a neurallike method of transformation with a network of direct propagation and the spacetime organization of connections. Authors think that the efficiency of computational structures can be increased by applying a developed method of PH transformation with the formation of the normalizing equation.
For quality classification and processing of a sequence of extended laser route spot images, a threshold criterion was introduced. Methods of PH transformation were developed by introducing a set A that contains measures of correspondence between the reference and current PH network tuning coefficients and by finding a measure of correspondence between two networks as a whole.
Using a normalizing equation, the processing and recognition algorithms for LBS images were developed, and the PH network structures for images based on Gtransformation were constructed. The developed algorithms allow the determination of energy center positions and classify laser route image frames. Peculiarities of realtime realization of the algorithm of the developed method for route fragments are discussed, and a choice of means for software development is explained. On the basis of the developed algorithms, software was created for modeling a neurallike parallel hierarchical network, which was used for image classification and fast processing. Experimental methods to study the processing of LBS image fragments were developed, which helped in verifying the adequacy of the developed algorithms and in obtaining the results of fast processing and classification of LBS image fragments.
In the conducted experiments, an average portion of good route fragments was 17%, as compared to 50% in [21]. However, after the training, it increased to 79.25% (as compared to 65% [21]). It was also established that an average rate of correct recognition was 94% (84.8% [21]), and the accuracy of energy center determination was no more than 0.01 decomposition elements (as compared to 1.2 decomposition elements [20]), which is reflected in Table 1. This is, on average, 1.5 times higher than the accuracy of known methods, for instance, based on the gravity center determination using a method of moment characteristics. Physical modeling of the method of PH transformation for fast image recognition using the Radeon X1300 graphic adapter demonstrates that processing of one image requires approximately 0.6 s (3.32 s [21]), and the network processing requires 1.52 s (8.4 s [21]).
References
 1.
Khosrofian JM, Garetz BA: Measurement of a Gaussian laser beam diameter through the direct inversion of knifeedge data. J Appl Opt 22 1983, : 34063410.
 2.
Basov NG, Zemskov EM, Il'kaev RI, Kazansky VM, Kirillov GA, Kulikov SM, Kutaev YF, Nosach OY, Sukharev SA: Laser system for observation and removal of space debris. Proceedings of GCL/HPL 98 vol. 3574, eds. A Boreisho and GA Baranov (SPIE, Bellingham, 1998), pp. 219–228
 3.
Timchenko LI, Kutaev YF, Kozhemyako VP: Method for training of a parallelhierarchical network, based on population coding for processing of extended laser paths images, in SPIE Proceedings, ed. AG Tescher (SPIE: Bellingham; 2002. pp. 465–479
 4.
GPGPU, General purpose computations on graphic processing unit . Accessed 16 April 2013 http://www.gpgpu.org
 5.
Wikipedia: Open computing language. . Accessed 16 April 2013 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OpenCL
 6.
NVIDIA Corporation: NVIDIA homepage. 2013.http://www.nvidia.ru/page/home.html . Accessed 16 April 2013
 7.
Chitty DM: A data parallel approach to genetic programming using programmable graphics hardware, GECCO '07. In Proceedings of the 9th annual conference on genetic and evolutionary computation. Edited by: Miller JF. New York: ACM; 1991. vol. 2, pp. 1566–1573
 8.
Luo Z, Liu H, Wu X: Artificial neural network computation on graphic process unit, IJCNN '05. Paper presented at the IEEE international joint conference on neural networks, Florida. 31 July–4 Aug 2005
 9.
Li JM, Wan DL, Chi ZX, Hu XP: A parallel particle swarm optimization algorithm based on finegrained model with GPU accelerating. Harbin Gongye Daxue Xuebao/J Harbin Inst Technol 2006, 38(12):21622166.
 10.
ChunYuan C, ChihHao C, MinAn C, AnYeu W: EURASIP Multiprediction particle filter for efficient parallelized implementation. J Adv Signal Process 2011, 2011: 53. 10.1186/16876180201153
 11.
Abel P, Plaza A: Clusters versus GPUs for parallel target and anomaly detection in hyperspectral images. EURASIP J Adv Signal Process 2010, 2010: 915639. 10.1155/2010/915639
 12.
Xu R: DC Wunsch II, Clustering. Hoboken, NJ: IEEE/Wiley Press; 2008.
 13.
Everitt D, Landau S, Leese M: Clustering Analysis. 4th edition. London, UK: Arnold; 2001.
 14.
Wunsch DC: ART properties of interest in engineering applications. Paper presented at the IEEE/INNS international joint conference on neural networks. Atlanta, GA; June 2009:1419.
 15.
Knuth D: The Art of Computing Programming: Fundamental Algorithms vol 1. 3rd edition. Boston: AddisonWesley; 1997.
 16.
MartnezZarzuela M, Pernas F, de Pablos A, Rodrguez M, Higuera J, Giralda D, Ortega D: Adaptative resonance theory fuzzy networks parallel computation using CUDA, bioinspired systems. Comput Ambient Intell 2009, 5517: 149156.
 17.
Gorchetchnikov M, Ames H, Versace M: Simulating Biologically Realistic Neural Models on Graphics Process Units. Boston: ICCNS; 2008.
 18.
Meuth RJ: GPUs surpass computers at repetitive calculations. Potentials IEEE 2007, 26(6):1223.
 19.
Martin AJ, Burns SM, Lee TK, Borkovic D, Hazewindus PJ: The Design of an Asynchronous Microprocessor. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press; 1986.
 20.
Kim S, Wunsch DC: A GPU based parallel hierarchical fuzzy ART clustering. Advanced Res 2003, 1: 27782782.
 21.
Timchenko LI, Kokryatskaya NI, Melnikov VA: Method of organization of a parallelhierarchical network for image recognition. J Cybern Syst Anal 2011, 47(1):140151. 10.1007/s1055901192973
 22.
Yarovyy AA, Vlasiuk RS: Intelligent System of Compression and Recognition of Images Designed for Laser Beam Profiling vol. 2. Ukraine: Vinnytsia National Technical University; 2010. pp. 1–11
 23.
Yarovyy AA, Vlasiuk RS: Simulation Modeling of Neuronetworking Recognition System of Multicolour Spotted Images of Laser Beam Profile vol. 3. Ukraine: Vinnytsia National Technical University; 2010. pp. 1–6
 24.
Jung SU, Chung YS, Yoo JH, Chung KI: U.S. Patent 007697734B2, Method and apparatus of detecting eye using symmetry and moment characteristics of object. 13 April 2010
 25.
Liao SX: Image analysis by moments. Thesis: University of Manitoba Winnipeg; 1993.
 26.
Prokop RJ, Reeves AP: A survey of momentbased techniques for unoccluded object representation and recognition. J Graph Model Image Process 1992, 54(5):438460. 10.1016/10499652(92)90027U
 27.
Teh CH, Chin RT: On image analysis by the methods of moments. J IEEE Trans Pattern Anal Machine Intell 1988, 10: 496512. 10.1109/34.3913
 28.
Wasson S: ATI's Radeon X1000 series GPUs: The graphics game changes again. Tech Report, October 5, 2005. . Accessed 16 April 2013 http://techreport.com/review/8864/atiradeonx1000seriesgpus
Acknowledgments
The authors express their gratitude to the scientific codirector of the work Yuri Kutaev for problem formulation and for his participation in its practical realization. Authors express their sheer gratitude to the team of the Chair of the Telecommunication Technologies and Automatics of the State Economy and Technology University of Transport (Kyiv, Ukraine) for the valuable comments and recommendations expressed in the course of the experimental research. Authors also thank Rector M.V. Makarenko, Vice Rector on Scientific Work Associate PhD V.I. Danilevskiy, and Dean of the Department of Infrastructure and Rolling Stock of Railway Transport Professor A.D. Voznenko for the provided facilities and equipment for scientific studies of this problem in the framework of the statefinanced scientific research topics.
Author information
Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Competing interests
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Authors’ original submitted files for images
Below are the links to the authors’ original submitted files for images.
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 2.0 International License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
About this article
Cite this article
Timchenko, L.I., Kokryatskaya, N.I. & Shpakovych, V.V. Modeling of a method of parallel hierarchical transformation for fast recognition of dynamic images. EURASIP J. Adv. Signal Process. 2013, 87 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1186/16876180201387
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Keywords
 Parallel hierarchical (PH) transformation
 PH network training
 Fast recognition of dynamic images
 Normalizing equation
 Classification and processing of images of extensive laser routes