Skip to main content

Table 2 The SSIM results of the denoised images by different denoising schemes

From: A wavelet denoising approach based on unsupervised learning model

Image

Method

σ=10

σ=25

σ=50

σ=70

σ=100

Barbara

Wavelet thresholding

0.8155

0.6022

0.4774

0.4185

0.2992

 

TV

0.8283

0.5996

0.5035

0.4997

0.4615

 

K-SVD

0.8996

0.7991

0.6410

0.5355

0.4453

 

BM3D

0.9112

0.8342

0.7193

0.6388

0.5390

 

Proposed approach

0.9608

0.9030

0.7938

0.7104

0.5977

House

Wavelet thresholding

0.7100

0.5564

0.5012

0.4368

0.3518

 

TV

0.8125

0.7503

0.6783

0.6423

0.5865

 

K-SVD

0.8446

0.7555

0.6667

0.5856

0.4970

 

BM3D

0.8687

0.7755

0.7120

0.6628

0.5914

 

Proposed approach

0.9536

0.9044

0.8362

0.7738

0.6721

Flinstones

Wavelet thresholding

0.8088

0.6614

0.4880

0.4151

0.3325

 

TV

0.8531

0.7568

0.5534

0.4814

0.4591

 

K-SVD

0.8697

0.7903

0.6935

0.6094

0.4830

 

BM3D

0.8686

0.8015

0.7272

0.6713

0.5920

 

Proposed approach

0.9391

0.8786

0.7978

0.7311

0.6294

Bridge

Wavelet thresholding

0.8492

0.6197

0.3855

0.3141

0.2718

 

TV

0.8588

0.6824

0.5184

0.4204

0.3207

 

K-SVD

0.8813

0.6770

0.4642

0.3864

0.3271

 

BM3D

0.8900

0.7013

0.5161

0.4402

0.3710

 

Proposed approach

0.9252

0.7870

0.6394

0.5618

0.4783

Fingerprint

Wavelet thresholding

0.9494

0.8462

0.6506

0.5507

0.4125

 

TV

0.9460

0.8620

0.7780

0.7084

0.3747

 

K-SVD

0.9647

0.8919

0.7411

0.5892

0.4160

 

BM3D

0.9636

0.8950

0.8043

0.7432

0.6600

 

Proposed approach

0.9701

0.9112

0.8276

0.7678

0.6690

  1. For each test setting, five results are provided: wavelet thresholding, TV, K-SVD, BM3D, and our proposed model. The highest SSIM values (best denoising results) are given in bold